Question about the report

Question about the report

par Bez Sea,
Nombre de réponses : 1

Dear Professor Bez,

I hope you are doing well.

As we are finalizing our Management Diagnostic Report on The Morning Star Company, due on Monday, we would like to clarify a few points to make sure we follow your expectations.

  • Abstract: Should we include an abstract at the beginning of the report, even though it is not mentioned in the guidelines? Like we can see on reports from previous year ? 

  • Notes to the CEO: We have presented our recommendations as short memos addressed to the CEO, using “To”, “From”, and “Subject”. Is this the expected format, or should we integrate our recommendations directly into the relevant sections?

  • AI and translation tools: Should the use of tools such as DeepL or ChatGPT for language assistance or writing support be acknowledged or referenced in the bibliography?

  • Figures: Should we include the sources of the figures and diagrams in the final bibliography, even if they are already cited in their captions?

Thank you very much for your time and clarification.

Best regards,

Zoé LE TRIONNAIRE

L3 IM MOMA 

Group H - Morning Star Company 

En réponse à Bez Sea

Re: Question about the report

par Bez Sea,
Thank you for your questions! I am sharing my answers with the whole class, as they are relevant to everyone, not just your group.

1. Abstract
An abstract is not required, as it is not mentioned in the guidelines. However, you are welcome to include a short executive summary if you think it adds value to your report.
Remember that the objective is to produce a clear and professional management analysis, not an academic paper.

2. Notes to the CEO
Presenting your recommendations as short memos addressed to the CEO (with "To", "From", and "Subject") is perfectly acceptable. In fact, I encourage you to think about how to communicate your recommendations effectively to a CEO.
What matters most is that your recommendations are clearly connected to your analysis, supported by evidence, and actionable. Avoid simply repeating your findings.

3. AI and translation tools
You can use tools such as DeepL or ChatGPT to improve your English, correct grammar, or enhance the clarity of your writing.
However, you must include a short statement at the end of your reference list explaining how you used AI tools, even if they were used only for language assistance.

If you use generative AI to develop ideas, structure arguments, or generate content, this must also be acknowledged transparently.

If any sections of your report are AI-generated, they must be explicitly identified as such, ideally specifying which AI tool was used and the prompt provided (for example, in a footnote).

Remember that you remain fully responsible for the accuracy, quality, and originality of your work.

4. Figures and diagrams
Yes, all external sources used for figures and diagrams should appear in your final reference list, even if they are already cited in the captions.
If you create your own figure based on external sources, indicate "Source: Adapted from..." and cite the relevant references.
If the figure is entirely your own creation, indicate "Source: Created by the authors of the report."

Important: Every figure must have a title, a source, and be explicitly referred to in the main text (e.g., "see Figure 1"). Figures should support your analysis, not simply decorate the report.

One final reminder: The objective of this report is not simply to follow a format but to demonstrate your ability to analyze an organization, apply management concepts, and develop relevant, evidence-based recommendations.

I look forward to reading your reports!

Best regards,
Sea BEZ